Story Published:
Jun 2, 2002 at 7:08 AM PST
Story Updated:
Aug 31, 2006 at 12:42 AM PST
SEATTLE - Although the whale-watching industry celebrates
orcas and draws attention to their plight, boats that follow the
majestic Northwest icons may pose their greatest risk.
Three studies being presented this weekend at the Orca Recovery
Conference at the University of Washington suggest the
whale-watching boats have helped cause the decline of an orca
population in the San Juan Islands.
"Based on the information we are releasing today, the primary
cause of orca death appears to be boats," Mark Anderson, founder
of the Orca Relief Citizens' Alliance, said Saturday.
The alliance, a nonprofit organization based in Friday Harbor,
commissioned the studies.
One suggests that noise from whale-watching boats is muddying
orcas' echolocation signals, which makes it more difficult for them
to hunt for fish.
Another study indicates that orcas are swimming faster and
breathing more quickly than they were in the mid-1980s, a sign the
animals are stressed out.
The third study shows that survival rates have declined most
significantly for males, especially older ones.
There has been no independent peer review of the studies, which
are not expected to be published until sometime next year, Anderson
said.
"This is a work in progress. There's much more to do," he
said. "It's a little as if there's been a crime, and pictures have
been taken, and we're watching those pictures develop."
Operators of whale-watching boats say they're already taking
steps to ease their impact on orcas, such as shutting motors off
within a mile of the whales.
"We want to do the right things, but you have to do them for
scientifically valid reasons," said Michael Bennett, who runs the
Mosquito Fleet, a whale-watching boat out of Everett.
Others who operate whale-watching boats agreed that the three
studies must be thoroughly reviewed by other scientists.
"I think obviously every perceived threat must be addressed,"
said Anna Hall, a University of British Columbia student pursuing
her master's degree in marine mammal research. She also works on
board a whale-watching boat off Victoria.
Guidelines recently set by the National Marine Fisheries Service
specify that boats should stay at least 100 yards away from orcas
and slow to 5 knots within 400 yards.
The population of southern resident killer whales off Washington
state and British Columbia has dropped from 98 in 1995 to 78 last
year, a 20 percent decline.
At the same time, the number of whale-watching boats has
increased - from 42 in 1994 to 82 last year.
"If you're a whale lover, as the boat operators themselves are,
would you spend 75 bucks to go out there if you knew that what you
were doing might be killing the whales?" Anderson asked.
Marc Pakenham, community adviser for Fisheries and Oceans
Canada, said the average number of whale-watching boats spotted
near orcas is much lower: 18.
Pakenham suggested several changes that could ease the stress
whale-watching boats cause orcas: establishing a permit process
that would require operators to control the length of their trips,
limiting the number of boats allowed in a given area or creating
sanctuaries where whale-watching boats are not permitted.
"What we have to do is establish some rules of engagement for
their habitat," Pakenham said.
Authors of the three studies were UW Professor David Bain;
Birgit Kriete, executive director of the Orca Relief Citizens'
Alliance; and Glenn VanBlaricom, an associate professor in the UW's
School of Aquatic and Fishery Sciences.
Other threats to orcas include oil spills, pollution from
industrial toxins and dwindling Northwest fish stocks.
"They tend to starve," Anderson said, "and as they starve,
they draw down their blubber, where all those toxins are, and they
get poisoned in the process."
Conservationists are asking the government to list the southern
resident orcas as endangered under the federal Endangered Species
Act. Biologists with the fisheries service are reviewing the
request, which was submitted more than a year ago.
Founded in 1997, Orca Relief Citizens' Alliance describes its
mission as learning more about what's causing the decline in the
orca population.
The three-day orca recovery conference ends Sunday.